Home | About Suzanne | News & Media | Email Updates | The Ledger | Contact
Dear Friends and Neighbors,
Last night, after one of the longest floor debate in Washington state history, the majority party in the state House passed a bill creating a Washington state income tax. I want to take a moment to explain what happened during this debate, why I opposed it, and why I believe this decision deserves careful attention from the people of our state.
After a debate that lasted over 24 hours, Democrats pushed the bill through despite significant constitutional concerns, widespread public opposition, and repeated efforts to amend the proposal to protect taxpayers.
Supporters have framed the bill as a tax that will only apply to certain high-income earners. However, the way the bill is written tells a different story. The fact is, this legislation establishes an income tax that applies to everyone, but currently includes a $1 million exemption. There is nothing in the bill that guarantees that exemption will remain where it is today. Lowering the threshold in the future would only require another vote of the Legislature.

That is one of the reasons many Washingtonians are skeptical of the promises being made about this policy.
There are also serious constitutional questions surrounding the proposal. For nearly a century, Washington courts have consistently held that income is treated as property under our state constitution, which requires property to be taxed uniformly. That precedent is why income tax proposals have repeatedly failed in our state, both in the courts and at the ballot box.
Washington voters themselves have rejected income tax proposals nearly a dozen times.
During the floor debate, House Republicans offered amendment after amendment aimed at protecting taxpayers and making life more affordable for Washington families. Those proposals included reducing the tax rate, protecting small businesses and pass-through income, exempting military and retirement income, lowering the state sales tax to provide relief to consumers, and requiring that any expansion of the tax be approved by voters.
Every one of those amendments was rejected.
Another concern that became clear during debate is the gap between political messaging and the actual language of the bill. Supporters repeatedly claimed the new tax revenue would fully fund school lunches for students. But that promise does not appear anywhere in the bill itself. Instead, the revenue flows into the general fund where it can be spent on a wide range of programs.
At a time when Washington families are already struggling with the cost of housing, groceries, fuel, and child care, many of us believe the Legislature should be focused on affordability and responsible budgeting rather than creating a brand-new income tax.
Major changes to our state’s tax system should not happen without the people having a direct voice in the decision. Unfortunately, amendments that would have allowed voters to weigh in were also rejected.

After 24 hours, the bill passed with no Republicans voting in favor. The debate itself was the longest floor fight any of us have ever experienced. While the outcome was disappointing, I remain committed to standing up for taxpayers and continuing to advocate for policies that make Washington more affordable for the families and communities I represent.
As always, thank you for taking the time to stay informed and engaged.

Suzanne Schmidt
